Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce Recipe

If you’re searching for a showstopping yet approachable seafood main, let me introduce you to Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce. Tender, perfectly spiced fillets of mahi mahi are nestled in a luscious, zesty sauce that’s brimming with bright lemon, savory garlic, and a touch of richness. This dish is the ultimate dinner for those nights when you want the wow factor with minimal fuss – the flavors meld together in minutes, but every bite feels like restaurant-level magic. Whether you’re feeding your family or hosting friends, Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce hits every note: fresh, creamy, tangy, and just a little bit fancy (without any of the stress).

Ingredients You’ll Need

The beauty of Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce is in its simplicity – every ingredient brings something important to the table. From the punchy flavors in the spice rub to the creamy, citrus-kissed sauce, each part creates an unforgettable meal with very little effort.

• Mahi mahi fillets: Choose firm, 1-inch thick fillets for the best texture and gentle sweetness – they hold up beautifully in the skillet and soak up the sauce.
• Olive oil and unsalted butter: This duo creates gorgeous golden edges on the fish and adds a depth of flavor right from the start.
• Flour: The secret to a well-seasoned coating; it gives just a hint of crispness under all that sauce.
• Garlic powder, onion powder, salt, paprika, pepper: An easy spice blend that wakes up the mild mahi mahi and adds color and warmth.
• Minced shallots: Shallots offer a gentle bite and subtle sweetness that lifts the whole dish.
• Fresh garlic: No lemon garlic cream sauce is complete without a big hit of real garlic for depth and aroma.
• Low sodium chicken broth: Provides flavor in the sauce without overwhelming the delicate fish.
• Heavy cream: This is what makes the sauce dreamy and silky, coating each bite.
• Cornstarch: A little thickens the sauce just enough, so it clings to the fish without feeling heavy.
• Dried parsley and dried thyme: These herbs pair perfectly with lemon and add an earthy, fragrant finish.
• Lemon juice: Adds the signature brightness and zing that balances out the richness of the cream.
• Salt and pepper: Essential for fine-tuning the flavors right before serving.
• Freshly chopped chives: The cherry on top if you want a pop of green and a gentle onion finish.

How to Make Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce

Step 1: Prepare and Season the Mahi Mahi

Start by mixing your flour, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, paprika, and pepper together in a bowl. Pat your mahi mahi fillets dry with a paper towel so the spice mixture sticks, then rub those spices in well. This is where you build the rich, flavorful base that shines through even after the sauce goes on top.

Step 2: Sear the Fish

Heat the olive oil and butter together in a large, heavy skillet over medium-high heat. Once the butter begins to foam, gently lay the fillets in and immediately turn the heat down to medium. Sear the fish for about four minutes on the first side so it gets a golden crust, then flip and cook for another two to four minutes depending on thickness. The mahi mahi should be opaque and just cooked through — don’t overdo it! Remove the fillets, tent with foil, and set aside.

Step 3: Build the Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce

If the skillet looks oily, drain off excess fat, leaving just about a tablespoon in the pan. Toss in the minced shallots, sautéing while you scrape up all those tasty browned bits for a couple of minutes until the shallots are soft. Stir in the minced garlic and cook for another 30 seconds — the aroma will be absolutely irresistible.

Step 4: Simmer and Thicken

In a small bowl or measuring cup, whisk together the low sodium chicken broth and cornstarch so there are no lumps. Pour this into the skillet along with the heavy cream, lemon juice, parsley, and thyme. Let the sauce gently simmer until it reduces by half and thickens beautifully, about four or five minutes. This is where the classic flavors of Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce come together. Season to taste with salt, pepper, and extra lemon juice if you crave even more brightness.

Step 5: Finish and Serve

Carefully nestle the mahi mahi fillets back into the pan, spooning the sauce over each piece so they’re coated in all that creamy goodness. Let them soak in the warmth for a minute, then finish with a scattering of chives or parsley if you like. Your Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce is ready to serve — irresistibly saucy and speckled with fresh herbs.

How to Serve Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce

Garnishes

Nothing beats a sprinkle of freshly chopped chives or parsley over the top for a burst of color and a touch of freshness. If you want to go all-out, a tangle of lemon zest curls or a few thin slices of lemon tucked alongside the fillets adds an elegant, restaurant-style flair that makes the presentation pop.

Side Dishes

This dish absolutely shines when paired with fluffy white rice, creamy mashed potatoes, or twirled pasta — all of which are perfect for catching every last drop of the lemon garlic cream sauce. Don’t forget a simple green salad or roasted asparagus for some lightness and crunch on the side.

Creative Ways to Present

For a special night, try serving Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce over a bed of wilted spinach or sautéed greens. Or, nestle the fish and sauce atop a warm lentil salad for a nutritious, textural contrast. If you’re serving a crowd, arrange all the fillets in a large platter with sauce drizzled generously on top and a scattering of edible flowers for a true celebration on a plate.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you’re lucky enough to have leftovers, store the mahi mahi and sauce in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three or four days. The flavors continue to meld, and it makes a fabulous next-day lunch or dinner — just be sure to reheat gently so the fish stays tender.

Freezing

While you can freeze the cooked mahi mahi fillets (without sauce!) for up to three months, freezing Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce as a whole isn’t recommended. The creamy sauce tends to separate and lose its wonderful texture once thawed, so save the sauce for fresh enjoyment.

Reheating

The best way to reheat Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce is gently, either in a skillet over medium-low heat or in the microwave in short intervals. Keep a close eye and reheat just until warmed through—this will help your mahi mahi stay moist and prevent the sauce from breaking.

FAQs

Can I substitute a different type of fish?

Absolutely! While mahi mahi is firm and mild, you can use other sturdy white fish like cod, halibut, or even grouper and get wonderful results. Just adjust the cooking time as needed so the fillets don’t overcook.

Is there a dairy-free way to enjoy this sauce?

You can swap out the heavy cream with coconut cream for a dairy-free version, but keep in mind it will bring a hint of coconut flavor to your Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce. Use a neutral, unsweetened coconut milk for best results.

Can I make the sauce ahead of time?

The sauce is at its creamy best when served fresh, but you can make it a couple of hours ahead and keep it warm in a covered pan. Give it a good whisk before serving to restore its silky texture.

What if my sauce gets too thick?

If your sauce thickens more than you’d like, simply thin it with a splash of chicken broth or a squeeze more lemon juice. Stir gently and let it come back to a simmer to meld the flavors.

Can I make Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce gluten free?

Yes! Swap the all-purpose flour for your favorite gluten-free blend or even a little cornstarch for the spice rub — the flavor and texture will still be delicious, and everyone can enjoy it.

Final Thoughts

Mahi in Lemon Garlic Cream Sauce is the kind of recipe you’ll want to make again and again, no matter the occasion. It’s easy enough for a busy weeknight yet special enough for company, and every element sings with fresh flavor. If you’re craving something light, creamy, and truly satisfying, give this dish a try — you might just find your new favorite way to enjoy fish!

Print